Vacuum Degreasers and Aqueous Solutions
Published

Non-hazardous Waste Becomes Hazardous Revisited

Question: Steve, your column in the September 2005 issue, non-hazardous waste has become hazardous, in which you describe how changes in process and wastewater pretreatment chemistry can have a profound impact upon the filter press cake’s status as a RCRA hazardous or non-hazardous waste reminded me of a situation we had about 10 years ago.

Share

Question:

Steve, your column in the September 2005 issue, non-hazardous waste has become hazardous, in which you describe how changes in process and wastewater pretreatment chemistry can have a profound impact upon the filter press cake’s status as a RCRA hazardous or non-hazardous waste reminded me of a situation we had about 10 years ago. At the time we had a captive metal finishing process and wastewater pretreatment system which had been producing a filter press cake that was non-hazardous. In fact, we tested it about every six months to make sure it remained non-hazardous. Out of the blue, the independent lab we used reported that chromium and lead were above their respective Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP) thresholds of 5.0 mg/liter. Needless to say we were in a panic and several loads had to be disposed as RCRA hazardous waste.

Fortunately, we had been using the lab for a number of years and had them go back to see if anything had changed. And, indeed, something had. For all the previous samples, the laboratory used TCLP extraction fluid #1 while for the filter press cake sample that flunked TCLP, they used extraction fluid #2. We then received a good education by the lab on the TCLP procedure (EPA test method 1311, Test Methods for Evaluating Solid Waste, Physical/Chemical Methods; EPA publication SW846).

When the filter press cake sample arrives at the lab, a portion is mixed with distilled/deionized water, and the pH of this slurry is checked. If the pH is less than 5.0, then the lab uses extraction fluid #1 which has a pH of 4.93.

If the pH is above 5.0, the lab takes another portion of the sample, mixes it with one normal (N) solution of hydrochloric acid (HCl), heats it up, allows it to cool, and again checks pH. If this pH is less than 5.0, the lab uses extraction fluid #1, but if the pH is greater than 5.0, the lab uses extraction fluid #2 which has a pH of 2.88, basically 100 times more acidic than extraction fluid #1. As expected, our filter press cake when mixed with the deionized water always had a pH above 5.0. In the past, after the acidification with hydrochloric acid, the pH would typically be between 4.5 and 4.9. Now, the sample exhibited a pH of 6.0 after acidification. What this told us was that, apparently, the alkalinity of our filter press cake had increased.

It did not take long to discover the reason. A few months before, our wastewater treatment operator found that by increasing the pH setpoints in our wastewater treatment system, the effluent became less cloudy and more clear although we had no compliance problems with the slightly “cloudy” effluent. We then restored the pH setpoints to their original values, waited several days to get the “old” sludge out of the system, and sampled filter press cake. Sure enough, its alkalinity had dropped so that the lab could use extraction fluid #1. We waited another week to make sure the process stabilized before taking another sample; it qualified for extraction fluid #1, and we had the TCLP performed on the sample, which passed just as in the past. Apparently, the increase in the filter press cake’s alkalinity was insufficient to overcome the more aggressive extraction fluid #2.

Feel free to pass this along to your readers. A.W.

Answer:

Thanks, A.W., and I thought I was the only one to experience this problem. Because of this issue, whenever we have TCLP performed on a sample, we request the lab to also report initial pH, pH after acidification with hydrochloric acid, extraction fluid used, and TCLP extraction pH. This has solved some headaches as wastes change, and we become detectives to find out why.

 

vacuum vapor degreasers
Precision Cleaning Solvents
Cleaning questions ask Kyzen
high-performance systems for efficient parts cleaning
Echoflex modular ultrasonic cleaning machines
Pickelx one step metal prep
Cleaning Technologies Group
OptiCenter All-in-One OC11
PF Podcast
Gardner Intelligence
plating and surface finishing additives
New Acid-Free Bright Nickel Process

Related Content

Liquid Coating

Defoamer Designed for Waterborne Coating, Printing Ink Formulations

Evonik’s Tego Foamex 812 exemplifies the company’s sustainability strategy for the paintings, coatings and inks industry.

Read More

NASF/AESF Foundation Research Project #120: Electrochemical Destruction of Perfluorooctanesulfonate in Electroplating Wastewaters - April 2022-March 2023

This NASF-AESF Foundation research project report covers project work from April 2022 to March 2023 at the University of Illinois at Chicago.  The overall objective of this work is to utilize a cost-effective reactive electrochemical membrane (REM) for the removal of PFAS from synthetic electroplating wastewater.  Initial results for the oxidation of PFOA with three different catalysts are discussed.    

Read More
nasf

NASF/AESF Foundation Research Project #122: Electrochemical Approaches to Treatment of PFAS in Plating Wastewater - 7th Quarterly Report

The NASF-AESF Foundation Research Board has selected a project on addressing the problem of PFAS and related chemicals in plating wastewater streams, studying PFAS destruction via electrooxidation and electrocoagulation.  Our last report described the results from experiments of EO with a Magnéli phase Ti4O7 anode on the degradation of eight perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs).  In this seven quarter report, we describe work to further explore how the degradation of different PFAAs are related to their molecular structures.

Read More
Parts Cleaning

Explore Cleaning Chemistry, Metal Finishing Applications and Wastewater Treatment Solutions

Hubbard-Hall Celebrating 175 years of excellence, Hubbard-Hall presents chemistry and equipment.

Read More

Read Next

Parts Cleaning

A ‘Clean’ Agenda Offers Unique Presentations in Chicago

The 2024 Parts Cleaning Conference, co-located with the International Manufacturing Technology Show, includes presentations by several speakers who are new to the conference and topics that have not been covered in past editions of this event.   

Read More
Sponsored

Delivering Increased Benefits to Greenhouse Films

Baystar's Borstar technology is helping customers deliver better, more reliable production methods to greenhouse agriculture.

Read More
Parts Cleaning

Education Bringing Cleaning to Machining

Debuting new speakers and cleaning technology content during this half-day workshop co-located with IMTS 2024.

Read More
Precision cleaning solvents