Gema Powder Coating
Published

Quoting E-Coat Costs

How can I quote e-coating a product line for a customer based on an average square-foot price without analysis of the parts?

Jose Tirado, Consultant, Ti6 Consulting International

Share

Q. I have a customer who wants me to quote his product line based on an average square-foot price without analysis of the parts. How can I accomplish this, since my selling price is basically based on the number of parts we can hang per carrier and number of carriers processed per hour? Also, what is the best way to calculate amount of e-coat applied per square foot of part? A.I.

A. To a certain extent, asking you to quote based on an average price per square foot without seeing the parts is not fair, since not all square feet coated cost the same. For example, a 1-sq-ft piece of 18-gauge galvanized is cheaper to electrocoat than a 1-sq-ft piece of ½-inch steel plate. 

If you currently price based on pieces per carrier or load, you must have a dollar value you want to generate per carrier/load. In order for you to obtain that value, you must have obtained some numbers from your profit/loss statement (P&L) that included all costs plus profit, divided by the number of loads you ran during the time frame you used the P&L. If you also had the square-foot number from all those loads, then you could calculate your actual cost per square foot equivalent to your value per carrier/load and provide that number to your customer. I have seen some job shops use this technique. It is easy, and quickly generates quote numbers, but it is not good enough to determine efficiency and competitiveness of the coater.

To be able to generate an average cost per square foot for all the parts, you must know every part size, weight and geometry; load density; line speed; and many other variables.

The theoretical cost of e-coating involves calculating the cost of the electrocoat material, pretreatment, waste treatment, sludge disposal, gas, water, sewer, electricity, direct and indirect labor (administrative costs, taxes), ultimately the profit you want. You must calculate each item one by one. Many custom coaters have all of this information in a spreadsheet so they can easily calculate the theoretical costs for quoting purposes and management control.

It is too long and tedious a process to explain here how to calculate all of your costs per square foot, but I will give you the calculations for the electrocoat paint.

First, you must know the percent solids of your electrocoat components. For this example, we will assume 30 percent solids and a 1,000-component material. If the e-coat you use is a two-component, then you must use the same calculation for both components and then ponder or weight the results by the mix ratio of the components. This calculation not only applies to e-coat but to all liquid paints as well.

Next, let’s assume that the cost of the e-coat per gallon is $25 and you are coating at an average of 20 microns. With that information, we first calculate the coverage as 1,604 × 0.3 × (25 ÷ 20), or 601.5 sq ft, where 1,604 is a constant for the U.S. system units, 0.3 is from your percent solids and 25 ÷ 20 a ratio of how thick your coating is.

Now we only have to divide the cost of the e-coat by the coverage calculated above: 25 ÷ 601.5, or 0.0416 cents/sq ft.

This is a theoretical calculation that indicates you can’t do better than that. However, you can do much worse, depending on how efficient you are in the use of the material and overall operation, including design and maintenance of the electrocoat machine.

Since I do not know the efficiency for your line and operation, I will assume 95 percent for the calculation. Applying this efficiency, your e-coat cost would be 0.0438 cents/sq ft, obtained by dividing the 0.0416 by 0.95.

To calculate actual efficiency, divide the theoretical number of 0.0416 cents by your actual cost. With this critical indicator, you can drive increases in efficiency by making improvements and saving thousands of dollars on electrocoat, pretreatment and other costs.

Your Best Finish Starts With Us!
Gardner Intelligence
Pretreatment Washer and Finishing Equipment
find masking products online
Filtration Systems
Heatmax Heaters ad with immersion heaters
PF Podcast
plating and surface finishing additives
Metal Pretreatment Technology
The Finishing Industry’s Education and Networking Resource
New Acid-Free Bright Nickel Process
OptiCenter All-in-One OC11

Related Content

Electrocoating

Top Shop Leader Focuses on Its People as Key to Success

Twin Cities job shop, Avtec, was named a Top Shop for the third time in 2022, due in no small part to its commitment not only to the work it produces but to those who produce it — its employees.

Read More
Powder Coating

TTX’s Automated Conveyor Carrier System Offers Wireless, Flexible Operation

ACC system designed for reliable, consistent point-to-point movement of everything from small to heavy parts.

Read More
surfin

Take Full Advantage of Industry Events

As travel plans ramp up for the year, what industry events will you attend? Products Finishing offers a quick look at some of the upcoming opportunities for 2024. 

Read More
basics

Conveyors and Paint Systems

Choosing the right conveyor system, coating technology, and ancillary equipment.

Read More

Read Next

Sponsored

Masking Solutions for Medical Applications

According to Custom Fabricating and Supplies, a cleanroom is ideal for converting, die cutting, laminating, slitting, packaging and assembly of medical-grade products.

Read More
workforce development

Education Bringing Cleaning to Machining

Debuting new speakers and cleaning technology content during this half-day workshop co-located with IMTS 2024.

Read More
regulation

Episode 45: An Interview with Chandler Mancuso, MacDermid Envio Solutions

Chandler Mancuso, technical director with MacDermid Envio discusses updating your wastewater treatment system and implementing materials recycling solutions to increase efficiencies, control costs and reduce environmental impact.

Read More
Bringing Powder Coating In-House, free download