Your Best Finish Starts With TTX!
Published

Fixing Penetration Issues in Recessed Areas of Parts with Electrostatic Applicators

Liquid coatings expert Steven Myers answers a reader’s question.

Steven Myers, Carlisle Fluid Technologies

Share

Q. We recently installed an electrostatic bell applicator and are having problems getting coatings into recessed areas of the parts. Is there anything we can do to help penetrate those areas?

A. Your problem is not specific to bell applicators. All electrostatic applicators (bell, disk, gun and so on) can experience something called the Faraday cage effect. When a coating is electrostatically charged and atomized, the charged atomized particles are attracted to the nearest grounded surface. When the target area is in a recessed portion of a part, it typically results in a higher film build along the edges of the recess, with little to no coating fully penetrating it.

Some non-specific applicator solutions include reducing the target distance, lowering the voltage, increasing the resistivity of the material and adjusting the atomization level. Looking at each of these in some detail could potentially solve the problem, no matter what type of electrostatic applicator you are using.

Reducing the target distance. Moving the applicator closer to the target area is the easiest solution. A general rule of thumb when using electrostatics is to maintain a safe distance of approximately 1" per 10 kV (kilovolts) from the grounded target surface. For example, when operating at 80 kV, a minimum distance of 8" would be recommended. If your current target distance to the recessed area is greater than the minimum recommended distance, you may be able to move in closer and get better penetration. This reduces the likelihood that charged particles will be pulled to the edges of the recess.

Lowering the voltage. In addition to producing lower particle voltage, this easy solution also potentially reduces the amount of the coating being pulled to the edges (the momentum of the particle more easily overcomes the associated net charge and penetrates the recessed area).

Increasing the resistivity of the material. When using any electrostatic application equipment, the resistivity of the coating material should be tested to ensure that it is within an acceptable range for the specific manufacturer’s equipment. Generally, for manual applications, the recommended range for resistance is 0.1 – ∞ MΩ (megaohms). For automatic application equipment, resistance in the range of 0.05 – ∞ MΩ is acceptable. Obviously, these are large ranges. Typically, the resistivity of the material can be changed by the type and amount of solvent used to reduce the material (the lower the resistance of the material, the more easily it is able to accept a charge). Highly charged coating materials are more apt to be pulled to the nearest grounded surface, leaving recessed areas relatively untouched. When the coating material is made more resistive, it does not readily accept as much of a charge and relies more heavily on particle momentum to reach the surface. This increases the potential to reach recessed areas.

Adjusting the atomization level. Smaller-sized particles are more easily pulled to the nearest grounded surface. Atomization affects particle size. Lowering the atomization air pressure to a gun results in a larger particle size. In your case, reducing the bell speed will result in a larger particle size, which makes it more difficult for the net particle charge to pull the coating material to the nearest grounded surface. This also increases the potential to reach recessed areas.

In your particular case, there are also a couple of additional, bell-applicator-specific options that could help to better penetrate the part recessed areas. These include changing the bell cup size and/or adjusting the shaping air. 

Typically, bell applicators support a wide variety of bell cup types and sizes, usually ranging from 15 to 70 mm. A 57-mm bell cup will produce a much larger spray pattern than a 30-mm bell cup, which could better reach recessed areas.

Shaping air is a bell applicator-specific parameter that will change both pattern size and particle velocity. This parameter introduces air around the edge of the bell cup surface. Increasing the shaping-air pressure will tighten and focus the spray pattern into a smaller area. A smaller, more focused pattern could also better reach recessed areas. In contrast to changing the bell cup size, shaping-air adjustments can be made while the bell is spraying, allowing greater flexibility during the coating process. If the part you are coating has both flat and recessed areas, the shaping air can be programmed to automatically adjust while spraying to better match the topography of the part.

Shaping air also affects particle velocity. A higher shaping-air pressure results in a smaller, tighter pattern and a higher particle velocity. A higher particle velocity will better “push” the coating material into the recessed areas while overcoming the electrostatic charge.

Because of the Faraday cage effect, it can be difficult to penetrate recessed areas when spraying with an electrostatic applicator. Sometimes just changing one of the above parameters will produce the results you are looking for, although the solution often requires making multiple adjustments to multiple parameters (for example, you may need to lower the voltage and increase the shaping air pressure). Every combination of application and coating is different. Your best approach is to adjust one parameter, check the effect and then adjust other parameters as necessary.

About the Author

Steven Myers

Steven Myers is a senior product manager with Carlisle Fluid Technologies.

Your Best Finish Starts With Us!
ENGINEERED PAINT BOOTHS & FINISHING SOLUTIONS
Precision gear pumps
New Acid-Free Bright Nickel Process
Filtration Systems
PF Podcast
Pretreatment Washer and Finishing Equipment
The Finishing Industry’s Education and Networking Resource
find masking products online
OptiCenter All-in-One OC11
Heatmax Heaters ad with immersion heaters
Heatmax Heaters ad with immersion heaters

Related Content

Powder Coating

TTX’s Automated Conveyor Carrier System Offers Wireless, Flexible Operation

ACC system designed for reliable, consistent point-to-point movement of everything from small to heavy parts.

Read More
Liquid Coating

Robots, AI and Superb BMW Surfaces

There isn’t an automotive paint shop in the world that doesn’t have post-paint inspection and defect processing. But BMW is doing this with levels of technology at a plant in Germany that exceed all other paint shops in the world.

Read More
economics

Henry Ford Is Still Right When It Comes to Color

Who would have imagined that more than 100 years after his famous statement about any color as long as it’s black would still have relevance of a sort?

Read More
Sponsored

Masking Solutions Provider CFS Dramatically Expands Capabilities and Capacity

Custom Fabrication & Supplies (CFS) completed a new plant expansion packing 10 times the capacity into twice the space. It dramatically enhances the supplier’s custom capabilities to provide extremely precise and cost-effective masking solutions.

Read More

Read Next

workforce development

Education Bringing Cleaning to Machining

Debuting new speakers and cleaning technology content during this half-day workshop co-located with IMTS 2024.

Read More
sustainability

Episode 45: An Interview with Chandler Mancuso, MacDermid Envio Solutions

Chandler Mancuso, technical director with MacDermid Envio discusses updating your wastewater treatment system and implementing materials recycling solutions to increase efficiencies, control costs and reduce environmental impact.

Read More
Sponsored

Masking Solutions for Medical Applications

According to Custom Fabricating and Supplies, a cleanroom is ideal for converting, die cutting, laminating, slitting, packaging and assembly of medical-grade products.

Read More
Industrial Finishing Equipment